Balancing State Responsibility

June 9, 2023

Empowering Independence and Addressing its Economic Implications in the UK

By Philip Francis Anderson, Activist and Podcast Host, Campaigning for Change.

Striking the Balance: Exploring the Tensions Between State Responsibility and Personal Empowerment for Individuals with Disabilities.

Introduction

The question of whether we should expect the state to be responsible for the survival and well-being of individuals with disabilities is a crucial and complex matter that requires careful examination. Balancing the state's role in safeguarding their survival and well-being with their autonomy and empowerment is of utmost importance. This blog post delves into the arguments for and against state survival dependency from their perspective in the UK, aiming to provide a comprehensive analysis of this multifaceted issue. By substantiating each perspective with sound reasoning, primary/secondary evidence, and relevant examples, we explore the challenges, benefits, and potential drawbacks associated with relying on the state for their survival and well-being.

Arguments for State Survival Dependency

Proponents of state responsibility argue that the state, as the primary governing entity, has a duty to ensure their survival and well-being. They contend that through inclusive policies and comprehensive support services, the state can create an enabling environment that promotes equality and access to essential resources. In the UK, legislation such as the Equality Act 2010 and the Care Act 2014 exemplify the state's commitment to protecting their rights and well-being. The provision of social welfare programs, accessible healthcare services, and reasonable accommodations in public spaces are essential components of state support that contribute to their survival and well-being. These initiatives help mitigate the additional barriers and challenges they face, promoting their integration into society and enhancing their quality of life.


Furthermore, the state's role in investing in infrastructure and transportation systems that prioritise accessibility is crucial. The implementation of disability-friendly features in public transport, buildings, and public spaces fosters their independence and social inclusion. For instance, the introduction of accessible buses, ramps, and disabled parking spaces in the UK has improved mobility and accessibility, allowing them to participate more actively in society.

Arguments Against State Survival Dependency

Critics of state survival dependency express concerns about the potential drawbacks and limitations associated with an overreliance on the state for their well-being. They argue that excessively relying on the state may inadvertently perpetuate a sense of dependency and undermine their empowerment. Critics caution that an overemphasis on state support might discourage self-advocacy and hinder opportunities for them to exercise their agency. They stress the importance of fostering an inclusive society that recognises their capabilities and contributions, encouraging their active participation in decision-making processes.


Moreover, critics raise concerns about the challenges and limitations of state-run services and systems in meeting their diverse needs. Instances of long waiting times for specialised healthcare services, inadequate provision of social care, and bureaucratic complexities in accessing disability benefits are cited as areas where the state's response falls short. Detractors argue that striking a balance between state support and individual responsibility is crucial to ensure that they have the autonomy to shape their own lives and make choices that align with their unique circumstances and aspirations.

Balancing State Support and Individual Responsibility

Finding the right balance between state support and individual responsibility is crucial for individuals with disabilities in the UK. While the state plays a significant role in providing support and creating an inclusive environment, it is equally important to promote self-determination and empowerment. The state should ensure that policies and services are designed in collaboration with them, taking into account their perspectives and lived experiences.


Empowering them involves promoting education, vocational training, and employment opportunities tailored to their specific needs. By investing in inclusive education and skills development, the state can equip them with the tools and knowledge necessary to lead independent lives and contribute meaningfully to society. Additionally, fostering entrepreneurship and offering targeted support for them to start their own businesses can enhance self-sufficiency and economic empowerment.


Simultaneously, promoting a culture of accessibility and inclusivity in all aspects of society is essential. The state should work towards removing architectural, attitudinal, and societal barriers that hinder the full participation of individuals with disabilities. Encouraging collaboration between the state, disability organisations, and local communities can help foster a sense of ownership and engagement, allowing them to actively shape policies and services that directly affect them.

An elderly woman rides a disability bike, accompanied by her guide dog.

Conclusion

In conclusion, achieving a balance between state support and individual responsibility is crucial when considering the survival and well-being of individuals with disabilities in the UK. This revised blog post has explored the arguments for and against state survival dependency from their perspective. It is evident that this topic encompasses multidimensional perspectives encompassing political, ethical, and social dimensions. Striking the right balance requires recognising the state's responsibility in providing necessary support and creating an inclusive environment, while also empowering them to exercise their autonomy and contribute actively to their own well-being. By fostering collaboration, inclusivity, and accessible opportunities, the state can help them thrive and create a society that truly values and respects the rights and contributions of all its citizens.

Comments Welcome!

To leave a general comment, feedback about a post, or even recommendations for a topic to cover, please just fill out this form. For those who would prefer to send their comment in using audio, there is the additional option to upload an audio file.

Contact Us

In line with GDPR, only complete this form if you are happy for me to use your answers for the purposes of processing of your request and in all

corresponding communications thereafter. Read my Privacy Policy for more information on how I manage your personal data. This contact form is also protected by reCAPTCHA, a Google system. Google's Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply and are available to read when using the reCAPTCHA tool.

Share by: